social_media

The 2019 version of an anti-social media bill has been read for the second time on the floor of the Nigerian Senate, paving the way for its passage into law.

Titled Protection from Internet Falsehood and Manipulation Bill 2019 (SB 132), it brings a government hammer into conversations hosted on social media platforms. Twitter and Facebook have become fertile ground for public discourse between Nigerians of different stripes over the last decade. Considerable success has been achieved by using these media to propel mass action on political and socio-economic issues.

The government now wants to impose an edit button. Political, anti-government speech is expected to be under particular scrutiny. Penalties for breaking the social media law include a fine of up to N300,000 or three years imprisonment for individuals and N10 million for corporate organizations.

Citizens and digital rights activists are voicing fears of potential impact on human rights and democratic expression. 

“No forward-looking country is seeking to gag their citizens in the guise of fighting fake news,” says Adeboye Adegoke, program manager at Paradigm Initiative, a digital rights organisation, to TechCabal. 

“Only totalitarian states are taking this approach.”

The naming of the bill is uncannily akin to military-era legislation used to suppress freedom of expression. That draconian law, Public Officers (Protection Against False Accusation) Decree No. 4 of 1984, was promulgated and enforced by current President Muhammadu Buhari when he was Head of State.

Boko Haram?

Muhammadu Sani Musa, a senator of the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) who proposed the bill, bases his defence on the need to thwart the influence of foreign ideologies.

He argues his bill is a firewall against people with “deep-seated prejudices in different countries [who] are using internet falsehood to surreptitiously promote their causes, as we have seen in Nigeria with the insurgency of Boko haram.”

It is unclear that every “foreign ideology” or “deep-seated prejudice” invariably produces opinions capable of terrorizing people. Without specific definitions, Musa’s logic rightly induces scepticism as to the true intentions of the bill.

Fighting “cancerous” fake news

Another prominent defender of the bill is Elisha Abbo, a senator under investigation for allegations of physical assault. Abbo, a member of the People’s Democratic Party (PDP), the main opposition party, supports the bill “holistically” because “if we cannot regulate the spread of falsehood, it will consume all of us.”

In June, CCTV recordings of him supposedly slapping a young woman in an Abuja sex toy store were widely shared on Twitter, proving the platform a useful medium for keeping lawmakers honest. 

To be sure, online misinformation is a scourge requiring deliberate policy attention. Advanced image and audiovisual manipulation technologies can fall into the hands of malicious actors. For the uninitiated, deepfakes are hard to distinguish from originals.

But as Chimaroke Nnamani, a PDP Senator from the south-east said while rejecting the bill, there is a CyberCrimes Act that caters to issues of slander and libel orchestrated on the internet. Devising another law for the same purpose is a covert means of creating limits on citizen expression, he said.

Protection from falsehood? More like protecting self-interest

Unlike in the days before social media, public officials are at greater risk of getting exposed for malfeasance today. Think the state governor caught stashing dollars in his kaftan, or bullion vans driving into a godfather’s residence. The social media bill is how members of the political class – regardless of party – push for stronger shields against the public’s eye. 

Adegoke says Senator Musa’s bill could be motivated by discomfort with being outed on social media as the supplier of INEC card readers for the March 2019 general elections. In any case, the bill appears a replication of Singapore’s Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act 2019 signed into law in June.

“Singapore is a very bad example to copy from, considering it ranks 151 out of 180 in the World Press Freedom Index,” Adegoke observes.

Who calls the shots?

Drafting a bill to gag social media is questionable enough. Setting up an arbitrary enforcement mechanism is a recipe for dysfunction.

Under the proposed law, law enforcement agencies will have regulatory powers over internet intermediaries. But intermediaries are already supervised by the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) per the Nigerian Communications Act 2003. Musa’s bill goes above and beyond, empowering law enforcement “to give directives to the NCC itself,” Adegoke says. 

Same enforcement agencies that “already have poor human rights records and are known to routinely abuse citizen’s rights.”

Supporters of this bill – and a similar one against Hate Speech – are determined to get what they want. Where the 8th Senate (2015 – 2019) failed, they hope to succeed. 

That will require the bill scaling a third reading after review by the Senate’s judiciary committee. Should it proceed to gain assent from President Buhari, it could herald an ominous turn in Nigeria’s democratic journey.

Read this next
The Real Battle Between Banks and Fintechs is just Beginning
Business, ecosystem, FinTech, Government, Mobile, News, Policy, startups, Technology
7th November 2019

The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) wants banks to lend more. This time it’s not just talking. It is compelling them, somewhat. But the new policy it has issued could set the stage for the first real tussle between banks and fintechs.

More From TC

Google’s Policy and Government Relations Lead (West/Francophone Africa), Titi Akinsanmi’s life and career, an intricately intertwined unit, are built on three pillars: a four-word mandate, a Latin mantra and actionable faith. On the evening we meet, she is preparing to attend Google’s end of year Christmas party in Lagos having been in the country a […]

yoco_south_africa

A year ago, venture capital fund Partech Africa gained attention following its investments in two promising African startups. South Africa’s Yoco provides portable point-of-sale machines to merchants, without contracts or monthly fees. TradeDepot, a Nigerian mobile B2B firm, gives retailers access to a wide range of goods directly available from FMCG factories. Yoco and TradeDepot […]

Business, Features, Funding
12th December 2019

Venture funding in Nigeria’s tech industry has been growing over the years. Yet most investments have come from funds domiciled abroad. Although VCs are increasingly launching funds aimed at investing in Nigeria and other African startups, only few of them keep their funds in Africa. And this has implications on how startups secure funding and […]

Jiji Secures $21 million as OList Becomes a Serious Challenger
Business, Funding, News, startups
10th December 2019

Jiji, the Nigeria-based classifieds listing company, has raised $21 million Series C funding from six investors. The round was led by Knuru Capital, an Abu Dhabi-based venture capital fund that focuses on late-stage companies. Founded in 2014 by Ukrainians Anton Wolyansky and Vladimir Mnogoletniy, Jiji is one of the biggest classifieds listing company in Africa. […]


TechCabal is a Big Cabal Media brand



Copyright © 2019
All rights reserved

Privacy & Terms